CO129-259 - Governor Sir Robinson - 1893 [5-8] — Page 157

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

153

freedom which belongs to all persons regardless of nationality who live on British territory and of abandoning a life of shame should they desire to do so.

20. For many years past, no girl under 21 has been allowed to enter a brothel until she has declared to the Registrar General that she is doing so of her own free will—after it has been explained to her that she is a free agent and at liberty to act as she likes. We are certain that a system which has undoubtedly had a good effect in the past in protecting the liberty of women and girls will, if abolished, lead to abuses arising, and that women and girls will be made to enter brothels who might have been rescued if they had had, as under the present system, opportunity of escaping from the clutches of those who treat them as mere chattels.

77

If it be argued that under the present system abuses exist, it cannot be denied that such is the case, but we submit that that is no argument for its abolition. We fear that it is impossible to eradicate all abuses in connection with brothels, but we have no hesitation in stating that these abuses have been minimised in Hongkong by the present system of registration, and that the inmates of brothels are more aware that they are free. Under the present system, too, the proper treatment of prostitutes is better secured than it would otherwise be. The inmates of brothels know that through the Registrar General, the protection of the Government is accorded to them, and that they can at any time complain to him. But if brothels can be opened and inmates put in them without ever having an opportunity of seeing...

Edit History

2026-05-27 01:29:18 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
153 freedom which belongs to all persons regardless of nationality who live on British territory and of abandoning a life of shame should they desire to do so. 20. For many years past, no girl under 21 has been allowed to enter a brothel until she has declared to the Registrar General that she is doing so of her own free will—after it has been explained to her that she is a free agent and at liberty to act as she likes. We are certain that a system which has undoubtedly had a good effect in the past in protecting the liberty of women and girls will, if abolished, lead to abuses arising, and that women and girls will be made to enter brothels who might have been rescued if they had had, as under the present system, opportunity of escaping from the clutches of those who treat them as mere chattels. 77 If it be argued that under the present system abuses exist, it cannot be denied that such is the case, but we submit that that is no argument for its abolition. We fear that it is impossible to eradicate all abuses in connection with brothels, but we have no hesitation in stating that these abuses have been minimised in Hongkong by the present system of registration, and that the inmates of brothels are more aware that they are free. Under the present system, too, the proper treatment of prostitutes is better secured than it would otherwise be. The inmates of brothels know that through the Registrar General, the protection of the Government is accorded to them, and that they can at any time complain to him. But if brothels can be opened and inmates put in them without ever having an opportunity of seeing...
Baseline (Original)
153 freedom which availing themselves of the right of belongs to all persons regardless of nationality who live on British territory and of abandoning a life of shame should they desire to do 20. For OV many years past girl 10 too. has been allowed to - enter a brothel until she has declared to the Registrar General that she is doing so of her own free will -after it has been explanned to her that لت لنا العالم free agent ana and at liberty to act as she likes. We are certarin that of this s And a systen which has undoubtedly good effect in the past in pro- fecting the liberty of be abolished, unavy wowe änd and girls abuses will arise, and that wornen and girls will be made to enter brothels who might have been rescued if they had had, as - under the prevent system, opportu. nity of escaping from the clutches of arr those who treat them as mere chattels. 77 Res Chart B If be may argued that under the_ present systern abuses exist. It cannot be denied that such is the case, but we submit that that is no argument for its abolition. We fear that it is urpossible to eradicate all abusesin connection with brothels, but we have. no beatation ui st stating that these abuses have been minimised in Hongkong by the present system of re- ofre. gistration, and that the minates of are learning brothels are mare avan Are that they are free. Under the present. - system too the proper treatment of pros. titutes is better secured thaw it would. otherwise be. The innates of brothels -Lockharts our know that through the Regiskar redine General the protection of the Govern_ They asser make ment is accorded to them, and that sime complain to can at any e opened plaints they Eny heine. But if brothels can be. and inmates nates put in them without ever ha r having an opportunity of seeing If
2026-05-27 01:29:18 · Baseline
View content

153

freedom which

availing themselves of the right of

belongs

to all persons regardless of nationality who live on British territory and of abandoning a life of shame should they desire to

do

20.

For

OV

many years past

girl

10 too.

has been allowed to

-

enter a brothel until she has declared to the Registrar General that she is doing so of her own free will -after it has been explanned to her that

لت لنا العالم

free agent

ana

and at liberty to

act as she likes. We are certarin that

of this s

And a

systen

which has undoubtedly good effect in the past in pro-

fecting the liberty of

be abolished,

unavy

wowe änd

and girls

abuses will arise,

and that wornen and

• girls will be

made to enter brothels who might have been rescued if they had had, as - under the prevent system, opportu. nity of escaping from the clutches of

arr

those who treat them as mere chattels.

77

Res Chart

B

If

be

may

argued

that under the_

present systern abuses exist. It cannot be denied that such is the case, but

we submit that that is no

argument

for its abolition. We fear that it is urpossible to eradicate all abusesin

connection with brothels, but we have.

no beatation ui st

stating that these abuses have been minimised in

Hongkong by the present system of re-

ofre.

gistration, and that the minates of

are learning

brothels are

mare avan Are

that they are free. Under the present.

-

system too the proper treatment of pros.

titutes is better secured thaw it would.

otherwise be. The innates of brothels -Lockharts our know that through the Regiskar redine General the protection of the Govern_

They asser make

ment is accorded to them, and that

sime complain to

can at

any

e opened

plaints they

Eny heine. But if brothels can be.

and inmates

nates put in them without

ever ha

r having an opportunity of seeing

If

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.